WhitmanTrading

What Inflation Does to Savings

Inflation is a fall in what money buys rather than a rise in prices, and it compounds the way interest does. At 3% a year the effect is large enough that savings held in cash lose more than a third of their purchasing power inside two decades.

How it works

A flat, quiet stretch of the long price series. The headline on the chart reads: Inflation is a fall in what money buys, not a price rise.
Inflation is a fall in what money buys, not a price rise. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

Inflation is usually described as prices going up. It is more useful to describe it as money buying less. The two are the same event, but the second framing puts the change where it actually happens — in the money you already hold.

And it compounds. Each year’s fall applies to what is left after the previous year’s, exactly like compound interest running in reverse.

The measurement

A gently rising stretch of the long price series with three purchasing-power curves below it. The headline on the chart reads: What one dollar still buys, at three rates.
What one dollar still buys, at three rates. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

One unit of money, held as cash, at three rates:

Rate After 10 years After 20 years After 30 years
2% $0.82 (−18%) $0.67 (−33%) $0.55 (−45%)
3% $0.74 (−26%) $0.55 (−45%) $0.41 (−59%)
5% $0.61 (−39%) $0.38 (−62%) $0.23 (−77%)

At a modest 3%, holding cash for thirty years loses 59% of its purchasing power. No statement ever shows that loss. The balance is unchanged; the thing it buys is not.

The gap between the rows is the part worth noticing. Two percentage points of inflation is the difference between keeping 55 cents and keeping 23 cents over the same thirty years.

A calmly advancing stretch of the long price series. The headline on the chart reads: Cash at zero percent loses slowly and without a statement.
Cash at zero percent loses slowly and without a statement. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

Cash is therefore not a neutral position. It is a position with a small, reliable negative real return, which is a very different thing from doing nothing.

In practice: the real return

A flat but volatile stretch of the long price series with a balance curve and a contributions line below it. The headline on the chart reads: A five percent return in a three percent year is two percent.
A five percent return in a three percent year is two percent. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

Subtract inflation from every return you are quoted. A savings account paying 2% in a 3% year is losing 1% a year in the only terms that matter. A 5% return in the same year is a 2% real return.

A strongly rising stretch of the long price series with three compounding curves below it. The headline on the chart reads: To stand still you have to earn the inflation rate.
To stand still you have to earn the inflation rate. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

Standing still requires earning the inflation rate. That is the hurdle every savings decision clears or fails, and it is why “keeping money safe” and “keeping money” are not the same instruction.

A 72-bar candlestick section of the shared price history. The headline on the chart reads: Wages are indexed late, if at all.
Wages are indexed late, if at all. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

Income adjusts late. Prices move continuously and pay reviews happen annually at best, so the gap opens first and closes afterwards, if it closes.

A declining stretch of the long price series with two falling debt-balance curves below it. The headline on the chart reads: And it quietly shrinks fixed-rate debt.
And it quietly shrinks fixed-rate debt. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

One thing it helps: fixed-rate debt. A mortgage fixed at a set payment is repaid in money worth less each year, so inflation transfers value from the lender to the borrower. That is the only place on this page where the arithmetic runs in your favour, and it applies only to fixed rates.

A long-horizon candlestick view of the same price series. The headline on the chart reads: Over thirty years it is the largest number on this page.
Over thirty years it is the largest number on this page. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

Over a retirement-length horizon, this is frequently the biggest single factor. Larger than the fee, larger than most of the return difference between reasonable strategies, and almost never modelled by the people it affects most.

What inflation is not

It is not the headline rate. The published figure describes an average basket. Your rate depends on what you actually buy — rent, energy, food and healthcare move differently from the average, and frequently faster.

It is not the same as a price rise. A single item getting more expensive is a price change. Inflation is the general fall in what money buys, and confusing the two makes it look like a series of unrelated annoyances.

It is not a reason to avoid cash entirely. An emergency fund buys certainty, and paying a small real cost for certainty is a reasonable trade — as long as it is a trade you made deliberately.

And it is not always positive. Prices can fall too, which sounds pleasant and is generally worse: it makes debt heavier in real terms and gives everyone a reason to postpone spending.

When it fails to be noticed

A sideways, range-bound candlestick series. The headline on the chart reads: The headline rate is not your rate.
The headline rate is not your rate. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

The characteristic failure is that nothing happens. No alert fires, no balance falls, no statement shows a loss. The account looks exactly as it did, which is why this is the easiest financial risk to carry for a decade without noticing.

A candlestick chart with a volume histogram beneath it. The headline on the chart reads: Your own basket is the only one that matters.
Your own basket is the only one that matters. Illustrative chart - not real market data.

The second failure is not resizing anything. A buffer built to cover six months of costs covers fewer months every year unless it is topped up, and the same applies to any target expressed in a fixed sum.

A third is comparing across decades without adjusting. A salary, a house price or a portfolio value from twenty years ago is not comparable to today’s figure, and most casual comparisons of that kind are measuring inflation rather than progress.

And a fourth is treating a nominal gain as a gain. An account up 3% in a 3% year has made nothing, and the tax is charged on the 3% regardless — which is covered on taxes on trading.

That last one deserves spelling out, because it is the least intuitive. Tax is charged on nominal gains in most systems, so in a high-inflation year an investor can pay real tax on a gain that was not real. The account grew in dollars, lost ground in groceries, and still generated a bill.

The practical response to all of this is short. Hold cash for the job cash does — the buffer, and money with a date on it — and expect the rest to at least clear inflation. Restate long-horizon targets in today’s money rather than in a fixed future sum, and revisit any figure you set more than a few years ago. None of that requires a forecast; it only requires applying the table above to numbers you already have.

The original data

1 of the 24,971 videos measured for this site covers inflation and savings, at a median of 34,273 views. A single video, a high median, and a topic that quietly determines whether every other number on this site means anything.

A candlestick chart of the site's shared price history, cut short at the decision bar. The headline on the chart reads: Savings pays two percent, prices rise three. Hold cash?
Savings pays two percent, prices rise three. Hold cash? Illustrative chart - not real market data.

The purchasing-power figures were computed for this page — a unit of money divided by compounding inflation at 2%, 3% and 5% over ten, twenty and thirty years. They are arithmetic rather than a forecast, and the reason to publish them is that almost nobody carries the 30-year number in their head.

Compound interest is the same mechanism working for you. The emergency fund is the cash position this page is really about. And net worth is the figure that should be read in real terms rather than nominal ones.

What I actually do

The thing that finally made this concrete for me was not a percentage. It was working out that the emergency fund I set up years ago needed to be about a third larger to cover the same months it was built to cover.

— Michael Whitman

This page is educational, not financial advice. Test every idea on your own charts before risking money.